I promised myself I would write about Koala Quill once I had tried it long enough to understand how it works. I don’t want to ramble, so I consolidate my thoughts in bullet points to my best recollection. (It still ends up like a ramble!)
Koala
Quill is a website made to motivate authors. The goal is to write every day, to
monitor and consolidate progress, to challenge oneself, and to manage the
effectiveness of one’s writing session with some incentives.
Interface
KQ is one of the cleanest and most effective websites I have ever encountered. I like the easy interface, and I have read through everything, although I still misremembered things and had to bother Philip a few times.
The
mobile version works great as well although most of the time I can’t see all
participants in popular guilds (same with desktop version, the expanding arrow
doesn’t always work), but this is minor.
It’s
not perfect for some other factors I will mention below, but overall, it still
works well for me.
Free
to sign up and ‘gamble’ with house money
This is the best factor to start. With all the scams going around and scammy ‘free trials’ that require bank details and the sacrifice of the firstborn, it’s easy to have trust issues. This (bank detail, not firstborn) would bounce me away before I start. KQ is free to sign up and you can also use a Google account.
Upon starting, user will be prompted to write, and as they write, they'll start earning. I didn’t know what to do, and I just stopped as soon as I could. If I remember correctly, I had 30 cents or something. Then I went into a panic mode again because I had to join a guild! Hold up, I'm not ready to commit, and I only had 30 cents! I was not ready to sell my kidney, and my neighbors were not around.
Fortunately, the cost of the guild would be on the house. If I lost it, it would be house money and my 30 cents. If I won it, I got it. Sounds great, right? The problem was that the available guilds might not be ideal for new users. It might have been ongoing for a while, which was the case for me. It’s not a pro-rated time you need to chase, but you are considered to be starting late with the same goal. I burned the midnight oil trying to catch up, and to my calculation, I had to be alive for 36 hours a day to catch up properly. I emailed Philip about this, and he added time for me, which made it possible for me to finish the guild on time.
Free
Visionary plan trial as the start
Visionary is the highest tier, where you can earn one dollar a day just by writing. As a struggling indie author who is inept in marketing, this helps me not to bang my head against the wall, at least there is something. In all seriousness (although I was dead serious with my previous statement), it's effective to motivate me to write. More on this later.
Free Visionary Plan lasted for one week, but I was given another week's extension. It wasn’t enough for me to earn the cost for Visionary membership (but it’s possible if you want to get a lower-tiered membership, Scribe), but it added up to something that doesn't look bad without any commitment.
Guilds
I have joined many guilds, but soon realized the options were not great. There was one that required users to write only one minute a day, and another that will only start in a year. I thought they were generated by the system, but no, they were created by the users (These two must have been created by some loony toons). A guild is some kind of ‘contest’ with ‘wager’ where you hope that your opponents are too lazy or too busy to fulfil theirs. The rules are clear. The easier the guild is, the more likely you won't earn anything.
As mentioned, I'm almost always part of guilds, and I have been here two and a half months, currently in four simultaneous guilds. I have created multiple guilds as well, but there were a few that passed by with no takers (chickens), mostly because I set a very high goal, like 40 minutes of writing within a short amount of time commitment, but I had a few popular ones as well. Low goal guilds attract a lot of sign-ups, but tbh, they are not attractive because you will likely lock your money for a long time without a payback, as everyone can easily fulfill the requirements.
In my experience, it’s hard to earn anything with guilds. I think I’ve only earned a few dollars with many zeroes or pitiful payouts in cents. Maybe I haven’t found a magic formula yet, and everyone is still very keen, which is a good thing, of course.
Just take note in case you have the same problem as I did. Guild follows my time zone automatically, which I assume follows respective users’ time zone as well. However, it gets confusing for me because by the time my guild ends, it hasn’t ended for others yet (since I live in the future, duh). I learned this the hard way when I celebrated my win over my sole opponent in a guild, which meant I was the winner, and I took a decent amount of winning! But nope, apparently, that sucker at the other end of the world still had plenty of time to finish it, and he did! There goes my dream of getting rich from a guild. Sometimes I fell behind as well because the day ‘changed’ without my knowledge about the actual timing.
I asked Philip about this and received the information that KQ operates in ETC/UTC, and most users use time zones such as America/New York, America/Los Angeles, and America/Chicago. I can change mine in the settings, so at least it’s easier for me to follow with the actual timing when a guild starts/ends. Some mixed-up might appear when you change your time zone, like the wallet breakdown so take note of that, but it shouldn’t affect the overall.
Warning
Emails
One thing that drove me nuts the first few times was the warning emails. I think it’s a template of something that doesn’t actually reflect the accurate progress in the guild. The first time I got it (or maybe I had missed the previous ones), it said that I would lose my money because I was falling behind. At that time, the guild was already over in my time, so I didn’t know what went wrong. I was sure I had finished it. I went to ask Philip, and he assured me that I was right. I still got the ‘inaccurate emails,’ like a few days ago, it warned me I was starting to fall behind with my guild, while I was actually 250 minutes ahead (around 8 days ahead and am close to the finish line. I have learned to be confident and ignore them, but it would be great if it reflected actual timing and didn’t try to send me into a panic mode.
Quill Mate
Okay, I have a strong opinion about this one, but I'm open-minded enough to admit that I could be wrong.
Whenever my brain is on fire, I write very quickly. I also have this insane competitive trait that I want to perform well. After looking at it (and reading about it), I decided to try one day. I clicked Join on someone looking for a quill mate. She had a ‘good’ star, so we started to write. I wrote a lot, and it ended up with me writing 20% more than her. I was happy with it.
The second time I tried was when I swore it off forever. This person had an okay star but not great, and asked for 20 minutes quill-mating. Again, I wrote quickly and realized it took a very long time, and the progress was not great. I could be reading it wrong, but I think I wrote 17 minutes while the other person wrote 2 minutes. I tried to slow it down to see if that was the case, but it still didn’t end (because he didn’t seem to be writing!). I finally wrote the last minute and we concluded it.
Quill
mate warning
Of course, at this moment, I was pissed enough, I got some ‘report’ that I wrote 160% more than my mate for that session. This was okay, lesson learned. However, when I checked on his profile, his reputation had risen significantly, bright and shiny with the same score as mine, which should be impossible, that he was a generous quill mate, while it was not the case at all. Tbh, this annoys me a lot, which means it was not his actual performance and that stat would fool his next quill mate. Again, I could be wrong in interpreting it, but I’m very sure he barely did anything during those 20 minutes. So, no more quill mates for . I do better on my own. I wish there were an easier way to see how this works.
Koala
Maze
As mentioned, when I am in the zone, I write quickly. Sometimes I had the pop-up with a green bar, which means there is more resting time as a reward, but when it happened, I would freeze and have a stage fright. However, more often than not, a koala maze would appear. I have to navigate the koala to pass the test that I’m not a bot. The thing was, I didn’t know what the koala liked! Strawberry? Car? Log? Joking. It’s easy enough, although it’s a true story that I got it wrong a few times because I was confused.
Payout
This might be everyone’s question. I am a very skeptical person, and I have trust issues with everything. I have read that KQ is legit, but it was only one or two articles, and to my knowledge, this is quite a new site. After my free trial ended, I thought I wanted to just stick with the Apprentice plan. However, I soon missed my daily motivation and the ability to join multiple guilds. I don’t have much hope of earning anything from guilds, but they are good motivations to write. I am not in a good financial place, but I want to invest in a good site and a good habit. The yearly plan was scary for me so I signed up for the monthly Visionary first, which cost $22. I want to verify and confirm that this is a legitimate site.
After a month had passed, I decided to upgrade to a yearly membership. Before that, here came the ultimate test: I’d try to cash out some amount of money through PayPal to see how easy or tedious it would be before I pulled the plug (or installed the plug?). It went well, so I went ahead with the yearly plan. Along the way, I also added to my balance so that I could join guilds for my 100k challenge motivation, and everything worked smoothly. Up to now, I can attest that this is a legitimate website and a good one to keep me motivated, which brings me to the next point.
Motivation
Writer's block be damned. There were times when I stopped writing altogether or just wrote a pitiful amount of words and called it a day. Personally, KQ raised my competitive self from the ground. I plan my schedule around it and would write much more before my busy days, so I wouldn’t fall behind the guild targets. I wrote during exercise, during walking like those phone zombies that I almost hit my forehead on an electrical pole. I avoided that, but then I hit the bottom of the escalator (true story) to fulfil my streaks. The 100k word challenge occurs during my busiest month, so I’m trying to write as much as possible before the holiday. It’s hard at times, but it really helps to get my butt out there.
Just like other users, I also realize that I’m too easily distracted. The amount of time I am in front of the screen and actually typing is horrible. Now that I have a time indication and a way to monitor it, it helps me to focus as well.
I would dig up something, a long-neglected WIP, a barely interesting competition (because I don't have good story ideas), and I actually started a new book because of this. I have been consistent, and according to the Koala on the top left, I have written 107k words since I joined in September (I have 71 streaks, so most likely that is the number of days I have joined), which is quite crazy because I remember dying a lot during multiple NaNoWriMo and only won once.
Other small stuffs
- It’s not easy to copy and paste a section of the draft (especially
the middle part of the draft) using a mobile phone, as it would get
chaotic in the same way as trying to move an image in Microsoft Word.
- Users have to be online to use KQ. Tthis is obvious, but a factor to
consider because I love to write offline or if users visit a place with bad/no internet
connection. There is an option to activate holiday mode.
- There is no actual community except for a limited chat function
during a quillmate section which
I never used. I don’t mind at all. Personally, it’s tiresome and it’s hard
for me to keep up. Not everything has to have a community.
- When copying and pasting a draft from Koala to other software,
sometimes the paragraphs are lumped together. Even publishing in KQ itself messes
up the paragraph spacing. (Update, this still shows up as a big lump
despite my effort in editing and fixing the spacing multiple times. I
think it’s major enough because it affects readability).
So, here is my long-winded ramble.
Koala in shining armor
Oh, there is one best point, Philip will appear like a knight in shining armor to help with any issue. I have asked some stupid questions, but he helped me all the same. I always advocate this kind of service because it’s irreplaceable. I think it’s great and one of my biggest reasons to be here.
Overall:
I really recommend Koala Quill.
You can use this referral link: https://koalaquill.com?rr=1877