The Blackened Yonder is the first book of the series. The
author plans for the series to have at least four books, based on a sentence I
read at the end of this one.
The book follows three PoV, which I get to read from two
different perspectives. This is one of my favorite styles because it’s always
intriguing to see the opposites of a coin. Unfortunately, besides some mentions
about the main conflict, the stories of both sides only start to integrate
about 75% into the book, which, imho, makes this style non-beneficial. It makes
me question the purposes, the timelines, or if they are in the same universe.
At some point in the story, I even wondered if Garron’s PoV is set in the past
for a brief period (it could be an awesome idea).
The characters start out very good. I’m invested in their
causes, stories, and inner struggles. However, it becomes repetitive near the
end of their journeys without much growth. I change from sympathizing with
Athenne to feeling indifference about her wishy-washiness. The revelation of
her backstory is also way too late and doesn’t have much impact to counter her
reason to join the Saint in the first place. Her main friend/love and one of
the reasons for leaning on her chosen path are probably not there for 90% of
the book, and readers know almost nothing about him. I appreciate the humanity
and how the two main characters are not following the path of The Chosen One,
but Athenne is barely more than a pair of eyes. I would rather see the story
from the other female Saint. (I will not attempt to spell more names)
The big task of the first book is that there are many names,
places, histories, and lore to learn. It is common in fantasy, especially when
it’s planned as a big series, however, some simplifications might help. For
example, it’s hard enough to refer to the character as one name, but using the
first name here mixed with the last name there and other attributes certainly
doesn’t make it easy to follow. I understand that it could be intentional,
depending on the conditions and the speakers, but it can work against the readers’
will to ensure who they are referring to. There are also a lot of ramblings at
the end of the book where some characters go on and on with their monologues.
I think the plot has good potential. There is enough going
on, but hopefully, the stories will be told by more intriguing characters.
(Amun is good, and I like how she is built up before taking the task.) The
world-building is rich, except for some questionable modern terminologies (I’m
not sure about the time setting, but epoxy resin doesn’t feel like it belongs
in this universe).
The best part of all is the writing style. It’s beautifully
written, very imaginative, and descriptive. I feel like I’m really there
absorbing the settings and scenery, where I can feel the grime on my skin,
smell the air, and hear the noise.
If you are a fantasy fan and want to invest in learning the
lore of everything in this universe and appreciate great writing, this book is
for you.
4 of 5